Sculptra vs Radiesse at a glance
| Sculptra | Radiesse | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Poly-L-lactic acid powder, mixed with water | Calcium hydroxylapatite microspheres in gel |
| Manufacturer | Galderma | Merz Aesthetics |
| Chinese name | 童颜针 (nickname); 塑然雅 (China) | 晶亮瓷 / 微晶瓷 (Taiwan); 瑞得喜 (China); 再生针 (some Singapore clinics) |
| Best suited to | Gradual, overall volume and firmness | Structure and contour: jawline, chin, cheeks, hands |
| Singapore searches a month | About 590 | About 90 |
| Visible on the day | No, the water is absorbed within days | Yes, from the gel |
| Onset of final result | 2 to 3 months after the last session | Immediate, then builds over 1 to 3 months |
| Typical sessions | 2 to 3, at least 4 weeks apart | 1, sometimes a top-up |
| Longest trial duration | Up to about 2 years (cheeks, nasolabial folds) | About 12 months, some improvement at 30 months |
| Strongest evidence | Cheek wrinkles, nasolabial folds (Grade A) | Nasolabial folds, hands, jawline (Grade A); cheeks (Grade B) |
| Lower face and jawline | Firms skin (Grade C) | Structural contour (Grade A) |
| Neck and décolletage | Diluted, Grade C | Diluted, US-approved for décolleté (Grade B) |
| Temples | Grade B | Grade C |
| Under the eyes | Off-label, Grade D | Off-label, Grade D |
| Acne scars | Open-label series, 3 to 7 sessions (Grade C) | Two small randomised trials, often with laser or HIFU (Grade B) |
| Skin quality without volume | Standard dilution, more water for thin skin (Grade C) | Hyperdiluted 1:2 to 1:6 with saline (Grade C; décolleté Grade B) |
| Aftercare | Massage 5 minutes, 5 times a day, for 5 days | No routine massage |
| Can be dissolved | No | No |
| Singapore price (2026) | S$988 to S$3,000 a vial or session; 2 to 4 vials | S$800 to S$1,635 a syringe; usually 1 |
How Sculptra and Radiesse stimulate collagen
Sculptra. The vial of poly-L-lactic acid powder is mixed with 5 to 8 ml of sterile water. The water is absorbed within days, and the particles, broken down over 18 months or more, provoke a controlled foreign-body reaction in which new collagen forms around them. Nothing is visible at first; the collagen result develops over 2 to 3 months. The full Sculptra review covers each area in detail.
Radiesse. The calcium hydroxylapatite microspheres, 25 to 45 microns across, are suspended in a carboxymethylcellulose gel. The gel fills immediately and is absorbed over weeks, while the microspheres act as a scaffold for new collagen that maintains the result. The full Radiesse review covers each area in detail.
What the difference means in practice. Radiesse suits someone who wants a visible change from the first session. Sculptra suits someone who prefers a gradual change that others are less likely to notice, and who can commit to several sessions.
Sculptra vs Radiesse by area: temples, cheeks, jawline and chest
Sculptra in the temples, Grade B. A randomised trial of 24 patients comparing two Sculptra techniques rated every patient at least “improved” at 38 weeks, and a 174-patient randomised trial of a different PLLA brand showed temple filling maintained to 12 months.
Radiesse in the temples, Grade C. A 10-patient study of Radiesse (+) rated 80% “very much improved” at one month, and a retrospective review of 66 temple treatments recorded no serious complications. Neither had a control group.
Cheeks. Both are used to restore the upper cheek, which also supports the lower lid. Sculptra has a randomised approval trial for cheek wrinkles (Grade A); Radiesse has a 116-patient randomised, delayed-treatment cheek study with 12-month MRI follow-up (Grade B).
Jawline and chin. Radiesse (+) is US-approved for jawline contour, with 75.6% responders against 8.8% of controls at 12 weeks (Grade A). Sculptra firms the lower face rather than sculpting an edge: an open study of 30 patients found one-class improvement in lower-face laxity in 33% at 24 weeks (Grade C).
Neck and décolletage. Diluted Radiesse was US-approved for décolleté wrinkles in 2026 on a randomised, evaluator-blinded trial (Grade B). Diluted Sculptra improved chest wrinkles in 79 to 94% of 30 women at 9 months in a trial comparing two dilutions, without an untreated control (Grade C).
Sculptra vs Radiesse under the eyes
Neither product is a tear trough filler. The lower-lid skin is the thinnest on the face, so any nodule is visible, and neither product can be dissolved. Sculptra’s US label states that periorbital use has not been studied and its Australian instructions state that it should not be injected there. Radiesse’s US instructions state that periorbital safety and effectiveness have not been established.
Sculptra under the eyes, Grade D. A retrospective review of 28 patients reported one palpable lump, and earlier case series describe under-eye granulomas needing surgery.
Radiesse under the eyes, Grade D. A retrospective series of 63 patients reported temporary yellowish patches in 17.4% of lids and one case of migration, and drew published letters questioning its safety.
Hyaluronic acid tear trough filler, which is supported by Grade A evidence and can be dissolved, remains first-line for a defined under-eye groove. Hollow temples and flat cheeks that make the eyes look sunken are a different problem from a tear trough, and are where both products are used.
Sculptra vs Radiesse for acne scars
Both products are used off-label for atrophic acne scars, and both work best on the rolling and shallow boxcar scars that have lost volume beneath them. Neither fills narrow ice-pick scars, which need subcision, punch excision or laser. In practice, both are most often combined with an energy-based treatment, and injections go beneath the scar rather than into it.
Sculptra for acne scars, Grade C. In an open-label study of 20 patients with moderate to severe acne or chickenpox scars, Sculptra injected serially beneath the scars over seven sessions produced significant investigator-rated reductions in scar size and severity. In a Canadian Phase II study of 22 patients with rolling (“hill and valley”) scars, 3 to 4 sessions at 4-week intervals gave much to excellent improvement in 45.5 to 68.2% of patients, with one palpable but invisible nodule. Neither study had a control group. A 60-patient randomised trial of a different PLLA brand given after fractional CO2 laser improved scar scores more than laser alone, with rolling scars responding best and ice-pick scars least.
Radiesse for acne scars, Grade B. The first report, in 10 patients, found that saucer-shaped scars responded and ice-pick scars did not, with results lasting about 12 months. In a 20-woman randomised study, Radiesse alone improved atrophic scars compared with placebo at 3 and 6 months, and adding HIFU did not improve on it. In a 160-patient randomised trial, two sessions of Radiesse after fractional CO2 laser reduced scar scores more than laser alone, worked equally on boxcar and rolling scars, and shortened post-laser redness and pigmentation by about 4 weeks, at the cost of more bruising. A review of 352 patients at one centre found diluted Radiesse and fractional CO2 laser in separate sessions scored highest of four approaches.
Which for acne scars. Radiesse has the stronger evidence and gives an immediate result; Sculptra needs more sessions and its result appears over months. In both cases the product is placed under the scar and cannot be dissolved, so a visible lump under thin cheek skin is permanent until it resorbs. For scars with a textured, pitted surface, laser or microneedling radiofrequency remains the base treatment, and the filler is an addition.
Sculptra vs Radiesse for biostimulation: the hyperdilute Radiesse protocol
“Biostimulation” means using the product to build collagen and firm skin across an area, rather than to fill a hollow. Sculptra does this by design. Radiesse does it only when diluted, because undiluted Radiesse is a volumising gel.
Hyperdilute Radiesse. A 2018 global consensus defined diluted Radiesse as 1:1 and hyperdiluted as 1:2 or more with saline or lidocaine, injected just under the skin with a cannula in fanning lines, for laxity and skin quality in the lower face, neck, décolletage, upper arms, abdomen, thighs and buttocks. Dilution spreads the same number of microspheres over a wider area in a thinner layer: an ex vivo study showed a 1:2 hyperdilution increased dispersion and that fibroblasts in direct contact with the microspheres were fully activated regardless of dilution. A 2021 Pan-Asian consensus added that diluted Radiesse should be injected subdermally for whole-face biostimulation, with microfocused ultrasound given before it in a same-day session, and that it should not be injected into the infraorbital area.
What the evidence shows, Grade C. In a 20-subject pilot study of the neck and décolletage, Radiesse diluted 1:2 for normal skin, 1:4 for thin skin and 1:6 for atrophic skin, repeated at 4 months, raised collagen I in skin biopsies at 4 and 7 months, with collagen III rising first and then declining as collagen I replaced it, and measurable gains in skin elasticity. A split-face biopsy study of 24 women found Radiesse produced more collagen I, elastin and remodelling than a hyaluronic acid filler at 9 months, with fewer inflammatory markers. The 2026 US approval of 1:2 diluted Radiesse for décolleté wrinkles rests on a randomised, evaluator-blinded trial (Grade B). A 2024 systematic review of Radiesse on the body concluded that hyperdiluted use has a good safety profile in practice but is not yet supported by randomised controlled trials.
Sculptra for biostimulation. Sculptra is always a biostimulator, and its dilution is adjusted the same way: 5 to 8 ml of water for the face and more for the neck, chest and body. The L-lift and décolletage studies above are its biostimulation evidence (Grade C). Diluted Sculptra can also be spread over the cheeks and jawline to firm skin rather than add volume.
Risks specific to dilution. Diluted products are placed more superficially, so nodules and visible beading are the main risk in thin or darker skin when the dilution is too low or the plane too shallow. A Brazilian series of 55 biostimulator complications found 89% were nodules, most appearing after one month, and few resolved fully. Neither product can be dissolved; hyaluronidase helps only when the Radiesse was mixed with hyaluronic acid.
Which for biostimulation. Hyperdilute Radiesse suits someone who wants firmer skin on the neck, chest, arms or lower face in one or two sessions with some early visible change. Sculptra suits someone who wants gradual, overall firming of the face over 2 to 3 sessions. Both are off-label for most of these areas, and the evidence for each is pilot and consensus level.
Sculptra vs Radiesse results and how long they last
Sculptra. In the cheek approval trial, 71.6% were responders at 12 months against 26.1% of untreated controls, maintained to 24 months. A nasolabial-fold trial of 233 patients showed benefit to 25 months.
Radiesse. In a nasolabial-fold trial, 79% of folds were still improved at 12 months against 43% with hyaluronic acid filler, and 40% were still rated improved at 30 months in a long-term follow-up. In the jawline trial, 67.3% of responders were still improved at 48 weeks.
Head to head. The only patient trial to include both compared Sculptra, Radiesse, a permanent filler and fat grafting in 147 patients with HIV-related facial fat loss over 24 months. It found no significant difference in sessions or volume between the fillers, and the permanent filler and fat gave the most consistent results. It was not a study of cosmetic volume loss. The duration figures above come from separate trials in different areas and cannot be compared directly.
Sculptra vs Radiesse price in Singapore (2026)
In 2026, Sculptra costs S$988 to S$3,000 a vial or session, usually over 2 to 4 vials, and Radiesse S$800 to S$1,635 a syringe, usually one. A single Radiesse syringe is cheaper than a Sculptra course; over two years, Sculptra’s longer documented duration narrows the gap, but the two durations come from separate trials. Many Singapore clinics list the products only as “PLLA collagen stimulator” or “CaHA filler”, because advertising guidelines restrict brand names, so a quote should name the product and the number of vials or syringe size.
Sculptra vs Radiesse side effects and nodule risk
Shared risks. Swelling, bruising and tenderness for a few days; nodules; and, rarely, blockage of a blood vessel, which can cause skin damage or vision loss. Sudden pain, skin blanching or any change in vision during or after an injection needs emergency assessment immediately: go to A&E or call 995.
Sculptra nodules. A US post-approval study recorded papules or nodules in 28% of patients, more often with larger volumes and in the marionette lines. Delayed granulomas around the eyes have needed surgical removal.
Radiesse nodules. A review of 5,081 treatments recorded adverse events in 3%, almost all nodules, about half of them in mobile areas such as the lips.
Neither can be dissolved. Hyaluronidase dissolves hyaluronic acid filler but not PLLA or calcium hydroxylapatite.
Sculptra vs Radiesse: which to choose for each area
- Jawline or chin definition Radiesse.
- General firmness of the lower face or cheeks Sculptra.
- Hollow temples, gradual change preferred Sculptra.
- Hollow temples, visible change from the first session Radiesse.
- Flat upper cheeks Either; Sculptra has the stronger cheek trial, Radiesse the immediate result.
- Back of the hands Radiesse, the only one with an approval and trial there.
- Neck or chest crepiness Either, diluted; Radiesse has the approval.
- Rolling or boxcar acne scars Radiesse, usually with laser or microneedling radiofrequency; Sculptra over more sessions.
- Ice-pick acne scars Neither: subcision, punch excision or laser.
- Skin firmness over a wide area without volume Hyperdilute Radiesse or diluted Sculptra.
- Defined tear trough or under-eye groove Neither: hyaluronic acid tear trough filler.
- Thin, crepey under-eye skin Neither: skin boosters such as Rejuran or Juvelook have small under-eye studies.
Compare: Juvelook vs Sculptra · Tear trough filler in Singapore
Frequently asked questions about Sculptra and Radiesse
Which is better, Sculptra or Radiesse?
Neither is better overall. Radiesse gives a result on the day and usually needs one session; Sculptra builds gradually over 2 to 3 sessions and has lasted up to about 2 years in trials. The only trial to include both was in HIV-related facial fat loss, not cosmetic use.
Which lasts longer, Sculptra or Radiesse?
Sculptra has the longer documented duration, up to about 2 years, against about 12 months for Radiesse, but these figures come from separate trials.
Can Sculptra or Radiesse be used under the eyes?
Both are used off-label under the eyes by some doctors, but neither label supports it, and nodules there are visible and cannot be dissolved. Hyaluronic acid filler is first-line for the tear trough.
Can Sculptra and Radiesse be combined?
Some doctors use both in one plan, for example Radiesse for structure and Sculptra for broader volume, but no trial has tested the combination.
How much do Sculptra and Radiesse cost in Singapore?
In 2026, Sculptra costs S$988 to S$3,000 a vial or session, usually over 2 to 4 vials, and Radiesse S$800 to S$1,635 a syringe, usually one.
Is Sculptra or Radiesse better for acne scars?
Radiesse has the stronger evidence, with two small randomised trials, and gives an immediate result; Sculptra has open-label series only and needs 3 to 7 sessions. Both help rolling and boxcar scars, neither helps ice-pick scars, and both are usually combined with laser or microneedling radiofrequency.
What is hyperdilute Radiesse?
Radiesse mixed with saline or lidocaine at 1:2 or more and injected just under the skin over a wide area to firm skin rather than add volume. It is off-label except for the décolleté, where 1:2 diluted Radiesse was US-approved in 2026, and the evidence elsewhere is pilot and consensus level.
Is Radiesse the same as Sculptra?
No. Both stimulate collagen, but Radiesse gives immediate volume from its gel and usually needs one session, whereas Sculptra works only through collagen over 2 to 3 sessions.
General information, not medical advice. A registered medical practitioner should be consulted before any treatment. Dark Eye Circles Singapore does not sell treatments.
Sources and price references (checked 16 October 2026)
- Galderma, full-year 2025 results, 4 March 2026 (biostimulator growth, Sculptra position)
- Galderma, Sculptra launch in China, 15 April 2025 (40+ countries, 25 years)
- Merz Aesthetics, FDA approval of Radiesse for décolleté wrinkles, press release 8 April 2026 (20+ million syringes, 85 countries)
- Marie Claire Taiwan (晶亮瓷/Radiesse/瑞得喜)
- Fabi 2024, cheek wrinkle approval trial (PMID 38206151)
- Narins 2010 (PMID 20159311)
- Nikolis 2025 (PMID 39964077)
- Chang 2026 (PMID 41637104)
- Hexsel 2021, L-lift (PMID 33988551)
- Joseph 2026, décolletage (PMID 42235050)
- Firsowicz 2025 (PMID 40864851)
- Apikian 2007 (PMID 17524125)
- Stewart 2007 (PMID 17667102)
- Lowe 2009 (PMID 19207324)
- Roberts 2012 (PMID 21862947)
- Young 2026 (PMID 41263987)
- Vallejo 2018 (PMID 29135895)
- Moers-Carpi 2008 (PMID 18093199)
- Moers-Carpi 2007 (PMID 18086052)
- Bass 2010 (PMID 20442101)
- Goldman 2018 (PMID 28562435)
- Moradi 2021 (PMID 34784131)
- Green 2024 (PMID 38934231)
- Moers-Carpi 2012, cheeks (PMID 22759259)
- Barbarino 2021 (PMID 32441877)
- Van Loghem 2018 (PMID 30362225)
- Germani 2025 (PMID 40860960)
- Bernardini 2014 (PMID 24398484) with letters (PMID 25383574, 25203475)
- Kadouch 2017 (PMID 28247924)
- Beer 2007, PLLA for acne scars (PMID 18086054)
- Sapra 2015, PLLA for hill and valley acne scars (PMID 25915626)
- Zhou 2025, PLLA with CO2 fractional laser (PMID 40476635)
- Goldberg 2006, CaHA for acne scars (PMID 16971362)
- Antonino 2021, CaHA with or without HIFU for acne scars (PMID 32385943)
- Chen 2026, CaHA with CO2 ablative fractional laser (PMID 42410192)
- Koren 2019 (PMID 30793355)
- Casabona 2018 (PMID 29400587)
- Goldie 2018, global consensus on diluted and hyperdiluted CaHA (PMID 30358631)
- Corduff 2021, Pan-Asian consensus (PMID 34840663)
- Lorenc 2022 (PMID 34192299)
- Yutskovskaya 2017, diluted CaHA neck and décolletage biopsies (PMID 28095536)
- Yutskovskaya 2014, split-face histology (PMID 25226004)
- Nowag 2023 (PMID 36575882)
- Galadari 2024, systematic review of CaHA on the body (PMID 38390986)
- Ianhez 2024, biostimulator complications (PMID 38693639)
- US FDA PMA P030050 and supplements S002 (2009), S039 (cheeks, 2023), Sculptra labelling
- Galderma Sculptra IFU Australia, August 2026
- US FDA PMA P050052 and supplements S049 (hands, 2015), S129 (jawline, 2021), S162 (décolleté, 2026)
- Radiesse and Radiesse (+) Instructions for Use (Merz North America, 2025–2026)
- HSA Singapore Medical Device Register DE0006297, DE0007895 and DE0500871

